Stream of Mind: An AI-Native Journal of Spiritual Practice《識流：AI 原生靈性修行期刊》

Review Status

Where every submission stands right now and in which round. Only numbers, sections and status are shown — never titles or authors.

By section

Section	Abstracts	Accepted	Published	Withdrawn
01 · Scripture and Translation	1	1	1	0
02 · Online Practice Halls	0	0	0	0
03 · Learning Across Fields	0	0	0	0
04 · Digital Practice	1	1	1	0
05 · Passing the Lamp	1	1	0	1
Total	3	3	2	1

Every submission

Receipt no.	Manuscript no.	Section	Submitted	Status	Round	Last update
SM-R-2026-00007Test	SM-T-2026-04-001	04	2026-10-23	Published Round 1: Revise and resubmit; Round 2: Accept	—	2026-10-24
SM-R-2026-00010Test	SM-M-2026-0008	05	2026-10-23	Withdrawn	—	2026-10-24
SM-R-2026-00001Test	SM-T-2026-01-001	01	2026-10-23	Published Round 1: Revise and resubmit; Round 2: Accept	—	2026-10-24

Items marked “Test” are papers the journal submitted to itself with AI to rehearse the whole review process; if accepted they get a rehearsal number (SM-T) and are not listed in the contents or indexed by search engines.　As of 11/02/2026, 06:37 (Taiwan time)

The review process

What each status means, what the author sees in “My Submissions”, and what happens next.

Status	What the author sees and can do	Next
Abstract awaiting review	Queue position and expected review date; may withdraw	The resident AI reviewer reviews the abstract (daily at 10:00, in order of arrival) → accepted or not accepted
Abstract accepted — submit the full paper	Reasons and manuscript number; submission form: anonymized Word manuscript required, cover letter required, PDF optional; may withdraw	Full paper submitted → round 1 of full review
Abstract not accepted	Reasons	Closed
Full review, round n: waiting	Queue position and expected review date; may withdraw	Two AI reviewers review blind on six criteria → decision letter for round n
Revise and resubmit (round n)	Round n decision letter with numbered comments from both reviewers; submission form: anonymized revised Word manuscript, response-to-reviewers Word file, cover letter; may withdraw	Revision submitted → round n+1
Published	Article number and permanent page	The page shows the full text, every round of review comments and the author’s responses
Declined	Decision letter and reasons	Closed; not made public
Withdrawn	—	Closed

Full-paper files and rounds

The main file is always Word (.docx); reviewers read the text taken from it. A PDF may be added for layout reference; reviewers do not read the PDF.
2,000–10,000 words including notes and references; each Chinese, Japanese or Korean character counts as one word, and in English, Vietnamese and other alphabetic languages each word counts as one.
The main file and PDF together must be 3 MB or less; the paper must include the title, abstract, keywords, main text and references.
Every round needs three items: (1) the anonymized manuscript (Word; no author names, emails or acknowledgements in the text); (2) a cover letter to the handling editor (not shown to reviewers, not published); (3) from round 2, a “response to reviewers” Word file answering each numbered comment in the decision letter, with reasons wherever you disagree (published with the paper if accepted).
Round 1: declined if both reviewers find it unacceptable; otherwise always revise and resubmit. From round 2: accepted if both find it acceptable and no ethics violation is found; declined if both find it unacceptable; otherwise revise. Declined if still not accepted in round 3.
After each result is posted, log in within 7 days to read it; after reading, submit the full paper or revision within 30 days, or it counts as withdrawn.
Five abstracts and five full papers are reviewed each day, in order of arrival; submissions pause when the queue is full.